West
Natick Neighborhood Association Meeting Summary
Summary of issues presented at WNNA
Meeting of 10/26/05
1.
Status of Mall Permitting. The Natick Mall has received permits
to expand into the Wonder Bread Factory site. Town meeting just rezoned the
site to allow condominiums, and a site plan review process will be required,
which is expected to begin shortly. As part of the process, the Planning Board
required that the Mall commit to significant mitigation, which was included in
the special permit. This mitigation requires the Mall to redesign, with town
input, various intersections and improvements. Some of the mitigation involves
the payment of money to the Town for which it is up to the Town to design and
implement. There are already some design drawings for proposed mitigation, in
particular for intersections directly adjacent to the Mall which will be
redeveloped by the Mall itself. Some sort of process will be required for the
town, mall and the neighborhood to reach agreement as specifically what shall
be done. (For all of the intersections, we will attempt to make the
preliminary engineering drawings available either in hard copy or on this
website. It appeared that a lot of the confusion at the meeting was because
people had a hard time visualizing what was being proposed.)
The sewer lines and water lines on
Speen Street will be upgraded to accommodate the Mall this coming summer, and
so there will be significant construction impacting all of us. Presumably the
Mall will begin reconstruction the Hartford Street intersection and adding the
pedestrian crossings (discussed below) at that time, since they need to
complete these as part of their approvals.
The following is a list of some of the mitigation
that will either be done by the Mall, or has been “earmarked” – meaning that
money will be contributed by the Mall, but it is up to the Town to determine
how to proceed.
A.
North of Route 9 (Mall Intersections). The Mall will be redoing
the intersections around the Mall.
·
This includes the intersection at the north end of the beetleback.
·
A new entrance to the Mall at the northern end of the expansion
will be included at the Speen Street roadway between the beetle back and Home
Depot.
·
A big issue at the hearings was the continuation of a proposed bicycle
path on the old railroad tracks, and how bicycles would cross Speen Street.
·
The Planning Board also required the Mall to include signage that
would direct traffic exiting the Mall going to the Mass. Pike to go by way of
the Shopper’s World connector road, rather than Speen Street/Route 30.
·
The Mall will also be spending a significant amount of money on
computerized signals for the intersections around the Mall. (If any of you
have gone through the Speen Street/Route 30 intersection before 6:00 a.m., you
will note that you don’t have to wait at that light if there is no traffic,
because it changes the instant you get there.)
In addition, the Mall will be required to develop a traffic
plan to attempt to deal with traffic during the holiday shopping season. While
traffic will continue to be a nightmare at Christmas, if there is some coordinated
effort with the Natick and Framingham police departments, there might be some
progress over gridlock.
B.
Fire Station Connection. If there is a fire at Sherwood Plaza,
it is very difficult for the fire trucks to navigate to the plaza, even though the
station is right next door. A direct connection, to be utilized only by
emergency vehicles, will be incorporated into the design, and a better
connection for the fire trucks to access Route 9 will be included.
C.
Sidewalks. The Mall has committed to upgrade sidewalks
surrounding the Mall and connecting to Speen and Hartford Streets in order to
make the Mall accessible on a practical level for pedestrians. (Having condos
at the Mall may create a constituency that also wants first class pedestrian
connections.)
D.
Speen Street/Hartford Street Intersection. This intersection has
been redesigned by the Mall and will be improved by them primarily by adding a
new left turn lane to Speen Street going south at Hartford Street. This will
not eliminate all to confused drivers who either miss the turnoff for Route 9
or meant to go north on Speen Street but got on the wrong exit, but it will
allow those who figure out quickly enough that they have made a mistake and who
can get into the left lane, to make a legal left turn onto either Route 9 or
Speen Street north without blocking traffic. Also, on Speen Street going north
at Hartford Street, the signs directing people to the Route 9 entrance are not
visible soon enough and unfamiliar drivers often have to cut across lanes to
get to Route 9. The Mall has committed to improve that signage.
E.
Speen Street/Nottingham Intersection. How to improve this
section will need a lot of input from both the expert engineers and from
residents. The merge from two lanes to one lane is problematic; however,
increasing the merging distance may only shift the problem to the Nottingham
intersection. Cars utilize Nottingham to u-turn when they have made a mistake
are a problem. Would it be better to prohibit left hand turns out of
Nottingham and force everyone to accomplish this u-turn by going to Hartford
Street? It is also possible that nothing radical will be done at this
intersection.
F.
Pedestrian Crossing. A commitment has been made to include
mechanical devices, pavement and geometry changes, and in-road lighting to
allow safe pedestrian crossings at three intersections on Hartford Street and
three intersections on Speen Street. How this is accomplished is a big
concern, as, while we like the idea of the addition of crossing aides, we all realize
that you take a big risk if you assume that everyone is going to stop. The
Mall is responsible to design and construct these 6 intersections.
G.
Turning Speen Street into a Residential Street. Over the length
of Speen Street (down to Route 135), the sidewalks and curbing on the east
side, which run for the length of Speen Street, are to be improved using better
materials and granite curbing. On the west side of Speen Street, granite
curbing will also be installed and sidewalks will be improved or added at the
upper end (probably not past the Golf Learning Center), and will be improved where
they exist from Lodge Road to Route 135. Lines denoting bicycle lanes will be
added. Some have proposed that trees be used to accentuate the residential
character of this street. The traffic rationale for these measures – granite
curbing, lines which artificially narrow the street, and some actual narrowing
of the street – will, we are told, have the effect of “calming” the traffic.
While there will still be plenty of room to pass cars making left turns onto
side streets, people will tend to go slower where there is a risk of damage if
a curb or tree is hit, and will tend to go slower simply because the bicycle
lines will give the appearance of narrower roadways. In addition, there was a
vision painted by Steve Cosmos, the landscape engineer hired by the planning
board to review the mall’s designs, that Speen Street needs to look like a
residential street and to be very distinctive compared to the commercial part
of Speen Street above Hartford Street – drivers need to know that they are
entering a residential area, and the trees, curbing, sidewalks, and other
factors need to “announce” that this is a residential area. This is also an
entrance to Natick proper and must be designed with that in mind. This is the
primary mitigation project that is under the town’s control. The Mall is
giving money, but it is up to the town to decide how to spend it to improve the
quality and character of Speen Street. The Mall is only giving partial funding
to all of the “vision” that was discussed for Speen Street, and so it is up to
the town to decide where to prioritize its resources.
2.
Other Construction Projects. Independent of the Natick Mall,
other construction projects are going on which will impact our neighborhoods.
A.
Route 135 Reconstruction. The improvements being made to Route
135 (in preparation for the state turning the roadway over to the town) are
nearing completion. Sidewalks now run from the CVS all the way to downtown.
Sidewalks also run up to the eastern edge of Roche Bros. The one piece that
has yet to be finished is a section of sidewalk on the south side of Route 135
in front of Roche Bros. (which is complicated by the fact that it has to be cavaliered
over the wetlands). That is expected to be completed by the end of June,
2006. When that is completed, pedestrian access should be easier.
B.
Right Turn at CVS. Feasibility studies for a right turn lane
from Route 135 west onto Speen Street north will be undertaken (in front of
CVS). This right hand turn lane would alleviate a traffic bottle neck, but
will also adversely impact the new pedestrian crossing at this intersection,
and needs to be studied to determine how best to safeguard the improved
pedestrian access. (CVS requested an extension of their “drive-through” window,
and the Planning Board required that they give the land in front that will
potentially accommodate a right turn lane.)
C.
Framingham and Wayland. The Natick Mall is also giving a
substantial amount of money to the Town of Framingham, and a small amount of money
to the Town of Wayland, because each of those towns saw the opportunity to get
something for nothing.
3.
Commercial Truck Traffic. Many of the issues relating to the volume
of traffic (other than the Mall’s holiday traffic) is a result of the fact that
we live in an area of high employment. Morning and evening rush hours are
gridlocked not because of the Mall, but rather because Speen Street is a
connector road for people trying to get to the Mass Pike or Rt. 9. However,
over the years, a number of commercial ventures that depend on trucks have been
allowed by Framingham and have increased truck traffic on Speen Street. Gravel
trucks go down Speen Street from Framingham to the facility south of Natick,
and several truck terminals located off 135 in Framingham and the Adesa car
auction facility in Framingham all utilize Speen Street. Whether trucks can be
excluded completely or partially from Speen Street is under the jurisdiction of
the Mass Highway Department, and traffic surveys at this time indicate that
volumes are not sufficient, however, new traffic studies will be undertaken.
Commercial vehicles have every right to use Speen Street at this time as long
as they abide by the law. However, the Natick police department understands
our concerns, and understands that even if a truck is not speeding, vehicles of
that size in a residential neighborhood going the speed limit can be, at a
minimum, extremely noisy and disruptive, and pose a danger.
To that end, the police department has used other options to
attempt to influence truck traffic.
·
For example, when the Mall was legally sending construction
trucks down Speen Street, the police and the planning department used their
leverage (i.e. the Mall will need to come before the town for additional
permits) to persuade them to not use Speen Street. The Mall has been extremely
cooperative, however, the haulers have cooperated only in some cases, but in
other cases have asserted their right to use Speen Street, and some have apparently
attempted to find ways around any restrictions the Mall puts on them.
·
Natick police have met with Adesa to provide information showing
that other routes to the Mass Pike are shorter and quicker. However, there are
problems with trucks utililizing Route 126 through Framingham (the at-grade railroad
crossing, and the fact that Framingham has “coincidentally” reconstructed parts
of Route 126 using traffic islands, etc. to make it more difficult for trucks
to navigate those roads).
·
The Natick police truck unit has also conducted inspections of
trucks on Speen Street. During periods when they set up operations, they pull
over every truck using the street and conduct safety inspections. This has the
effect of insuring that trucks maintain safe speeds, operate vehicles safely,
but also has the effect of letting the truckers know that they are being
watched, and perhaps discourages use of Speen Street. Part of the problem has
been maintaining traffic flow while pulling over trucks, and a recent solution
to deal with that problem has been to gain permission from the Natick Army
Depot to use their parking lot for pulling trucks over. The Natick police have
also conducted surveys of roadway usage, including speed and type of vehicle,
and this information will be used in part to determine if a case can be made to
exclude trucks from all or part of Speen Street.
# 1395754 v1 - wadswojw - 009999/0001