Some of the Movies I Like, and Why

The movies

Why I like them

Saving Private Ryan

Fresh

Sleepers

The Breakfast Club

Alien

(I can't help but take the Aliens movies as a package. They have the same kind of continuity in my mind that Star Trek had for me up until about 5 years ago.)

Aliens

Alien 3

Alien: Resurrection

Young Frankenstein

Earth Girls are Easy

The Day the Earth Stood Still

Star Trek: First Contact

Ok, I'm not going to pretend that Star Trek: First Contact is the best movie I have ever seen, but it does trumpet the real problem with the Federation that all of those Gene Roddenberry groupies seem to have overlooked: everyone in the Federation is the same...there aren't any individuals left.

Now, I am sure that you are asking yourself, "How can a movie about the Borg going back into time to destroy Earth's future have anything to do with the Federation turning everyone into happy conformists?" Well, that's just it. The Borg represent the Federation's shadow.

Yes, that's right, Jungian psychology. The Borg are a symbol for what the Federation doesn't want to admit about itself--the Federation crushes individuality in favor of the "greater societal good"; if you don't fit in, you won't get anywhere. The only way to stand out is to either take the risky path of Starfleet or the toe-the-line path of Federation politics. Why else would the Maquis be outlaws?

Sure, the Federation doesn't use the violent tactics of the Borg, at least, not on individuals. But think about the amount of resources that have been given over to the hunting of the Maquis. Surely, such a small group couldn't be that much of a threat to the largest peaceful federation of states in the galaxy? I mean, the Federation supposedly thrives on diversity.

You see this reinforced constantly in the current series, since the diverse, non-hegemonic political body known as the Voyager had to be separated from it's own society--the one where it might actually have some influence--the Federation. The Federation just gives lip service to diversity. Differences are threatening.

Resistance is futile. You will be assimilated.

(And they just had to get that mother the destroyer archetype in there, too.)

I also think that Jonathan Frakes has a great career ahead of him, considering the amount of movie experience he was working with on this film, and the good balancing act he pulled off with being a major character in the film and directing.